(Began in 1993)
| 1993 at Oregon State | |
| Session II Results (April 15) | |
| 1. Utah | 196.325 |
| 2. Arizona | 194.025 |
| 3. Auburn | 193.775 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 193.425 |
| 5. Penn State | 192.700 |
| 6. Arizona State | 192.175 |
| 1994 at Utah | |
| Session II Results (April 21) | |
| 1. Alabama | 196.300 |
| 2. Utah | 194.925 |
| 3. Florida | 194.250 |
| 4. Oregon State | 193.625 |
| 5. Louisiana State | 193.225 |
| 6. Arizona State | 190.825 |
| 1995 at Georgia | |
| Session I Results (April 20) | |
| 1. Georgia | 196.825 |
| 2. Michigan | 195.700 |
| 3. Utah | 195.325 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 193.025 |
| 5. Nebraska | 191.750 |
| 6. West Virginia | 189.650 |
| 1996 at Alabama | |
| Session II Results (April 25) | |
| 1. Alabama | 196.325 |
| 2. Utah | 196.000 |
| 3. Oregon State | 195.700 |
| 4. Arizona | 195.125 |
| 5. Florida | 194.825 |
| 6. Stanford | 194.025 |
| 1997 at Florida | |
| Session I Results (April 17) | |
| 1. Georgia | 197.075 |
| 2. UCLA | 196.425 |
| 3. Nebraska | 196.025* |
| Utah | 196.025* |
| 5. Penn State | 194.300 |
| 6. Louisiana State | 193.825 |
| *Nebraska won the tiebreaker to advance to the Super Six. | |
| 1998 at UCLA | |
| Session II Results (April 16) | |
| 1. UCLA | 196.925 |
| 2. Florida | 196.750 |
| 3. Utah | 196.200 |
| 4. Washington | 195.450 |
| 5. Louisiana State | 195.300 |
| 6. Penn State | 194.625 |
| 1999 at Utah | |
| Session II Results (April 22) | |
| 1. Georgia | 197.025 |
| 2. Michigan | 196.575 |
| 3. Nebraska | 196.225 |
| 4. Utah | 195.475 |
| 5. Penn State | 194.775 |
| 6. Florida | 194.000 |
| 2000 at Boise State | |
| Session I Results (April 13) | |
| 1. Georgia | 196.775 |
| 2. Utah | 196.125 |
| 3. Alabama | 196.075 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 194.950 |
| 5. Oregon State | 194.750 |
| 6. Brigham Young 194.500 | |
| 2001 at Georgia | |
| Session II Results (April 19) | |
| 1. Georgia | 197.100 |
| 2. Utah | 196.575 |
| 3. Nebraska | 196.200 |
| 4. Stanford | 195.400 |
| 5. Arizona State | 194.775 |
| 6. Denver | 193.625 |
| 2002 at Alabama | |
| Session I Results (April 18) | |
| 1. Utah | 196.775 |
| 2. Georgia | 196.650 |
| 3. Nebraska | 196.575 |
| 4. Michigan | 196.175 |
| 5. Louisiana State | 195.850 |
| 6. Arizona | 194.975 |
| 2003 at Nebraska | |
| Session II Results (April 24) | |
| 1. Nebraska | 197.325 |
| 2. Utah | 196.850 |
| 3. Georgia | 196.625 |
| 4. Florida | 196.325 |
| 5. Stanford | 196.200 |
| 6. Auburn | 193.525 |
| 2004 at UCLA | |
| Session II Results (April 15) | |
| 1. UCLA | 197.675 |
| 2. Alabama | 197.325 |
| 3. Utah | 196.925 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 196.650 |
| 5. Michigan | 196.500 |
| 6. Arizona State | 196.325 |
| 2005 at Auburn | |
| Session I Results (April 21) | |
| 1. Utah | 196.850 |
| 2. Michigan | 196.575 |
| 3. Nebraska | 195.875 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 195.800 |
| 5. Penn State | 194.975 |
| 6. Oklahoma | 194.425 |
| 2006 at Oregon State | |
| Session I Results (April 20) | |
| 1. Nebraska | 196.325 |
| 2. Alabama | 196.250 |
| 3. Utah | 196.175 |
| 4. Michigan | 196.000 |
| 5. Louisiana State | 195.650 |
| 6. Oklahoma | 195.525 |
| 2007 at Utah | |
| Session II Results (April 26) | |
| 1. Utah | 197.325 |
| 2. Stanford | 197.200 |
| 3. UCLA | 196.475 |
| 4. Louisiana State | 196.275 |
| 5. Denver | 195.575 |
| 6. Michigan | 195.100 |
| 2008 at Georgia | |
| Session II Results (April 24) | |
| 1. Georgia | 197.625 |
| 2. Utah | 196.950 |
| 3. Stanford | 196.900 |
| 4. UCLA | 196.725 |
| 5. Michigan | 196.075 |
| 6. Denver | 194.200 |
| 2009 at Nebraska | |
| Session II Results (April 16) | |
| 1. Alabama | 197.025 |
| 2. Arkansas | 196.950 |
| 3. Utah | 196.625 |
| UCLA | 196.625 |
| 5. Oregon State | 195.350 |
| 6. Illinois | 195.050 |
| *Utah won the tiebreaker to advance to the Super Six. | |
| 2010 at Florida | |
| Session I Results (April 22) | |
| 1. UCLA | 196.875 |
| 2. Utah | 196.625 |
| 3. Oklahoma | 196.550 |
| 4. Nebraska | 196.175 |
| 5. Oregon State | 196.050 |
| 6. Louisiana State | 196.025 |
| 2011 at Cleveland | |
| Session II Results (April 15) | |
| 1. Alabama | 197.050 |
| 2. Nebraska | 196.850 |
| 3. Utah | 196.200 |
| 4. Florida | 196.125 |
| 5. Oregon State | 196.100 |
| 6. Kent State | 195.000 |